Wednesday, 12 February 2014

Post 40- Third draft feedback from a professional editor

One member of our group went away and contacted a professional editor in order to gain some adequate feedback from our third draft. This draft bearing in mind did not have any special effects, which we told the editor this was the case. Contacting this person was important because we wanted some feedback from a different perspective. The previous feedback we do have is from media students or close friends, so it was essential we gain feedback from someone who has not seen the film before or had any experience with a film like this. Down below is a screenshot of the email the editor sent to us, giving detailed feedback.











From looking at the feedback above,  myself and the group consequently changed the editing:
  1. At the beginning, the title would be better if it appeared when Thomas sat up. Also we should make the shot longer, in order for the title to still be present when Thomas leaves the shot. However, we found that if we did this, the lighting of the shot would change and be less effective. So, overall, we altered it so that the title appeared sooner.
  2. It would be more effective if the kitchen scene was cut shorter because it was unnecessary for it to be so long. We made a mistake of not cutting out the beginning of the scene where the director said "action".
  3. From the feedback, it was essential that we added the special effects to the wedding album otherwise the audience would be confused about what is happening to Thomas.
  4. To make it sound like the music was coming from Thomas' headphones, we had to take out the bass of the music so it sounds more quiet.
  5. This feedback was similar to other feedback we have had. This is because some people didn't quite understand how Thomas got to the tunnel or what he was drawing.
Overall, this professional editor has given some constructive feedback which we have taken and furthermore improved our film. The main improvement which was needed was the fact we needed to cut frames off some of the clips, so it flowed better. As the editor didn't see the final product with added special effects, it's difficult to say whether there would be more to improve on.

No comments:

Post a Comment